Saturday, February 14, 2004
cut-and-pasted
This oakley*centre : Electronic Voting Machines leans a bit on conspiracy. I don't think you have to bother with that.
The Internet and electronic voting companies are incompetent.
There's a mix of start-ups, giant consultancies, and players in-between.
None of these people have the slightest clue about doing secure voting.
They just want you to buy their crummy machines and technology.
I must say Cringely does make a good point about Diebold.
They're all "paper receipt, how will we ever do that, that will be so complicated".
Meanwhile, practically every single electronic transaction we make generates a paper receipt.
Use your ATM? Paper receipt.
Lottery kiosk? Paper receipt.
Debit card? Paper receipt.
In fact, you would have to deliberately redesign your system specifically not to provide a paper receipt.
The oakley page says
The Leong Star article is 11,708 sign up for Markham Web vote
These people have absolutely no understanding of how using the Internet undermines the election process.
Here's one example: I want you to vote for that Meditation Party, the one that is always hopping around.
With a paper ballot filled in privately in a public place, you can assure me you are going to vote for me and then inside the booth, you happily fill in the Anti-Trancendentalists.
With Internet voting, I drive over to your house and point a gun at your head until I see you click on the desired party.
Big improvement, yes?
Or if I'm more into non-violence, I put a keylogger trojan on your Windows computer (assuming it can fight it's way onto your system amidst all the other spyware, adware, backdoors, open proxies and trojans you already have). When I see you go to the election site, I silently change your vote to be the one I want.
I can go through hundreds of scenarios like this.
Is there a list of these Internet / electronic voting companies somewhere?
This oakley*centre : Electronic Voting Machines leans a bit on conspiracy. I don't think you have to bother with that.
The Internet and electronic voting companies are incompetent.
There's a mix of start-ups, giant consultancies, and players in-between.
None of these people have the slightest clue about doing secure voting.
They just want you to buy their crummy machines and technology.
I must say Cringely does make a good point about Diebold.
They're all "paper receipt, how will we ever do that, that will be so complicated".
Meanwhile, practically every single electronic transaction we make generates a paper receipt.
Use your ATM? Paper receipt.
Lottery kiosk? Paper receipt.
Debit card? Paper receipt.
In fact, you would have to deliberately redesign your system specifically not to provide a paper receipt.
The oakley page says
Canadian provinces and municipalities are slowly succumbing to lobbying from Diebold and other electronic-voting players .... Melissa Leong of the Toronto Star reports
The Leong Star article is 11,708 sign up for Markham Web vote
7.5% of voters want 'e-ballot'
City clerk predicts shift to Internet
These people have absolutely no understanding of how using the Internet undermines the election process.
Here's one example: I want you to vote for that Meditation Party, the one that is always hopping around.
With a paper ballot filled in privately in a public place, you can assure me you are going to vote for me and then inside the booth, you happily fill in the Anti-Trancendentalists.
With Internet voting, I drive over to your house and point a gun at your head until I see you click on the desired party.
Big improvement, yes?
Or if I'm more into non-violence, I put a keylogger trojan on your Windows computer (assuming it can fight it's way onto your system amidst all the other spyware, adware, backdoors, open proxies and trojans you already have). When I see you go to the election site, I silently change your vote to be the one I want.
I can go through hundreds of scenarios like this.
Is there a list of these Internet / electronic voting companies somewhere?
Comments:
Post a Comment